Value Red Burgundy: Seven Reds That Over-Deliver
By Josh James
Every year the headlines from Burgundy seem to say the same thing: smaller harvests, bigger demand and prices that keep climbing. The famous names of the Côte d'Or are now well beyond what most of us would open on a Tuesday night, and it's easy to assume good red Burgundy has priced itself out of reach.
It hasn't. In a world where prices are rising, it's enlightening to know that real value is still there, if you know where to look. Some of my favourite bottles right now come from the edges of the map: the Côte Chalonnaise, the Hautes-Côtes above the great villages, and the quieter vineyards of the Auxerrois. These are the wines I keep coming back to, made by serious families who care just as much as their more famous neighbours.
Where the value hides
The Hautes-Côtes. Up in the hills behind the Côte de Nuits and Côte de Beaune, the vineyards sit higher and cooler. Warmer vintages have been kind to these slopes, and many top Côte d'Or domaines farm vines here, so you get their skill and their style at a fraction of the price.
The Côte Chalonnaise. South of the Côte d'Or, villages like Rully and Givry make Pinot Noir with real depth and structure. Their Premier Crus can sit comfortably alongside village wines from much better-known addresses.
The Auxerrois. Near Chablis, the Côtes d'Auxerre makes bright, fruity, silky Pinot Noir that's easy to love and kind on the wallet.
Well-chosen village and Grand Cru wines. Even on the Côte d'Or, there are lieux-dits and climats that over-deliver for what they cost. You just have to know the growers.
Seven reds that over-deliver
2023 Domaine Grand Roche Bourgogne Côtes d'Auxerre Pinot Noir, $54. A family estate in Saint-Bris, founded by Erick Lavallée in 1987 and now run by his children, Caroline and Clément. This is 100% Pinot Noir from a young 0.75-hectare vineyard, aged in seasoned oak. Bright red cherry and raspberry with a gentle thread of spice, silky tannins and a cheerful, fresh finish. Lovely with charcuterie, roast duck or mushroom dishes.
2023 Domaine Michel Gros Hautes-Côtes de Nuits Rouge 'Au Vallon', $71. From one of Vosne-Romanée's great family names, Au Vallon is a sun-soaked, south-facing slope in the Hautes-Côtes. Ripe cherry and raspberry, a gentle lick of spice and a silky, generous palate that glides to a fresh finish. Rated "Outstanding" by Burghound. Beautiful with roast chicken, pork or charcuterie.
2023 Domaine Jaeger-Defaix Rully 'Clos du Chapître' Premier Cru Rouge, $99. A one-hectare walled monopole behind the family house in Rully, farmed organically with low yields and raised for 12 months in barrel, about 10% new. Red cherry, raspberry and oak spice, with fine tannins. A Premier Cru at a weeknight-friendly price, and 94 points from Christy Canterbury MW.
2024 Domaine Ragot Givry 'Clos Jus' Premier Cru, $105. The Ragots have grown vines since 1760, and Nicolas now farms this east-facing hectare of red clay and limestone at the very top of Givry. Wild yeasts and 12 to 15 months in oak give deep colour, blackberry, liquorice and spice, with a broad, structured palate. Lovely now with grilled red meat or brie, and it will reward four or five years in the cellar. Jasper Morris MW gave the 2023 91 points and called it "a deep, dense, sensual wine, still with excellent structure".
2024 Domaine Jérôme Chézeaux Nuits-Saint-Georges 'Les Charbonnières', $120. A family estate in Premeaux-Prissey since 1930, from old vines on a 0.67-hectare village lieu-dit. Fermented with indigenous yeasts, unfined and unfiltered. Nuits-Saint-Georges under $130 is getting rare, and this is a natural match for beef, lamb or mushroom risotto.
2023 Domaine Hoffmann-Jayer Hautes-Côtes de Nuits 'Cuvée Rosalie', $129. Formerly Jayer-Gilles, from 0.37 hectares of about 50-year-old vines at Magny-lès-Villers. It's made only in exceptional years, just three barrels or about 740 bottles, and bottled unfiltered. Forest berries, a chalky line and a silky texture. We have only six bottles.
2024 Domaine de la Pousse d'Or Corton 'Bressandes' Grand Cru, $300. The one worth stretching for. Pousse d'Or is one of Volnay's great estates, and Les Bressandes is among the most respected red climats on the Corton hill. Dark cherry, plum and spice, with firm, fine tannins that will reward time in the cellar. Burghound gave it 93 points and called it "bigger-bodied, succulent and energetic". Grand Cru Burgundy at this price is a rare thing, and we have just three bottles.
Getting the most from these wines
- Serve them a touch cool. Around 15 to 16°C keeps Pinot Noir fresh and lifted. Twenty minutes in the fridge before opening works wonders on a warm Melbourne evening.
- Use the right glass. A wide-bowled Burgundy glass lets the perfume open up.
- Drink some, keep some. The Grand Roche, Au Vallon and Rully are lovely now. The Ragot, Chézeaux and Rosalie will happily sit for a few years, and the Corton deserves patience.
- Keep the food simple. Roast chicken, duck, pork, mushrooms and good charcuterie let these wines shine.
Value is still out there
Burgundy will probably never be cheap again, but it doesn't have to be out of reach. These seven reds are proof that thoughtful growers in the right places are still making wines that deliver far more than their price suggests. Quantities are small, so if one catches your eye, I wouldn't wait too long.
And if you'd like a hand finding wines like these for your own cellar, our Private Cellar Master service is where we come in. We'll get to know how you drink, source the bottles that are hard to find, and look after your cellar so the right wine is always there when the moment calls for it.
Cheers,
Josh